In its storied history, Doctor Who has weathered many changes, but none perhaps as controversial and detrimental as its recent revival under Russell T Davies and the casting of Ncuti Gatwa as the Doctor. Once hailed as a beacon of imaginative science fiction, the show now finds itself teetering on the brink of cancellation, marred by glaring issues that threaten its legacy and viewership.
The return of Russell T Davies, celebrated initially as a nostalgic nod to the show’s golden age, has instead led Doctor Who down a path of creative decay. Davies, known for his groundbreaking work in resurrecting the series in 2005, seems to have lost touch with the essence of what made Doctor Who resonate with audiences worldwide. Instead of revitalizing the show with fresh ideas and compelling narratives, Davies has steered it towards a shallow and pandering direction.
Central to this decline is the portrayal of Ncuti Gatwa as the Doctor. Gatwa, known for his role in Netflix’s “Sex Education,” brings an entirely different energy to the character, one that many argue is more focused on style over substance. Critics and fans alike have noted Gatwa’s portrayal as lacking the gravitas and depth that previous Doctors brought to the role. Instead of embodying the Doctor’s characteristic blend of wisdom, eccentricity, and moral complexity, Gatwa’s Doctor appears to prance around, avoiding the serious issues that once formed the backbone of the show’s storytelling.
The viewing numbers tell a grim story. The first six episodes under Davies’ return have seen some of the worst ratings since Doctor Who’s inception, reminiscent of the troubled times when the show struggled against “Coronation Street” in the late 1980s. Audiences, it seems, are tuning out in droves, disillusioned by what they perceive as a betrayal of the show’s core identity.
Perhaps most damning of all is the accusation that Doctor Who has devolved into a “gay Kardashians dating show,” abandoning its roots in science fiction for a shallow focus on sensationalist interpersonal drama. While Doctor Who has always been progressive in its representation and themes, critics argue that under Davies’ helm, these elements have overshadowed the intricate storytelling and moral dilemmas that once captivated viewers of all backgrounds.
The heart of Doctor Who has always been its ability to weave complex narratives, explore profound philosophical questions, and challenge societal norms through the lens of science fiction. Under Russell T Davies’ return, this heart seems to have been eclipsed by a misguided attempt to appeal to contemporary trends and surface-level entertainment.
The return of Russell T Davies and the casting of Ncuti Gatwa as the Doctor have proven disastrous for Doctor Who. What was once a cultural touchstone has now become a cautionary tale of how misguided creative decisions can erode the very essence of a beloved series. Unless drastic changes are made to reclaim its former glory, Doctor Who risks fading into obscurity, a tragic end for a show that once inspired generations with its boundless imagination and timeless storytelling.
Doctor Who’s Groundbreaking Gay Kiss: Progress or Pandering?
Doctor Who has once again made headlines, not for its compelling storytelling or imaginative plots, but for what some herald as a groundbreaking moment: the Doctor sharing a passionate kiss with a dashing bounty hunter named Rogue, played by Jonathan Groff. This event, which occurred during a romp through Bridgerton-era England, has sparked both praise and criticism, raising questions about the show’s direction under Russell T Davies’ return and Ncuti Gatwa’s portrayal as the Doctor.
Firstly, the kiss between the Doctor and Rogue is framed as a historic first for the Time Lord’s same-sex love interests. However, this claim overlooks previous instances, notably Captain Jack Harkness’s kiss with the Ninth Doctor (Christopher Eccleston) almost two decades ago. Captain Jack, played by John Barrowman, has been a longstanding representation of LGBTQ+ visibility in the Whoniverse, paving the way for such moments well before this recent episode. Therefore, while the kiss with Rogue is significant, it’s not the revolutionary milestone it’s portrayed to be.
Critics argue that Doctor Who’s recent narrative decisions, including the focus on romantic subplots and celebrity guest stars, detract from its core identity as a science fiction series. The episode featuring Rogue and the Doctor has been described as more about steamy romantic tension than exploring the complexities of time travel and moral dilemmas. This shift, they argue, risks alienating longtime fans who were drawn to Doctor Who for its thought-provoking stories and innovative concepts.
The comparison drawn to a “gay Kardashians dating show” underscores a perception that Doctor Who under Davies’ stewardship has prioritized sensationalist interpersonal drama over substantive sci-fi storytelling. This sentiment is exacerbated by Davies’ own legacy of infusing social commentary and LGBTQ+ representation into the series during his previous tenure. However, critics contend that recent episodes have leaned too heavily into pandering to contemporary trends rather than maintaining the show’s unique blend of adventure and intellect.
The portrayal of Ncuti Gatwa as the Doctor has also come under scrutiny. While Gatwa brings charisma to the role, some viewers find his interpretation lacking the depth and gravitas seen in previous incarnations. The Doctor, historically a figure of immense moral authority and intellectual prowess, is now seen by some as reduced to a character whose primary narrative arc revolves around romantic entanglements and personal relationships rather than the broader implications of time and space.
While Doctor Who’s inclusion of a gay kiss between the Doctor and Rogue is a step forward for LGBTQ+ representation in mainstream media, it also highlights deeper concerns about the show’s creative direction. The emphasis on celebrity guest appearances and romantic subplots risks overshadowing the series’ rich history of exploring profound themes through the lens of science fiction. For Doctor Who to reclaim its status as a pioneering force in television, it must strike a delicate balance between inclusivity and innovation, ensuring that each episode resonates not just for its headlines but for its enduring impact on the hearts and minds of its audience.
The End
As Ncuti Gatwa’s first full series as Doctor Who unfolds on BBC One, creator Russell T Davies has provided insights into the show’s future. In an interview with Radio Times, the 61-year-old revealed plans for a Christmas special this year and confirmed that the 2025 series has already been filmed. Looking further ahead, however, Davies acknowledged uncertainty, noting that the commissioning of future seasons remains undecided, a common scenario in television production.
“We’re currently working on the fourth script for season three,” Davies shared cautiously. “It’s not officially commissioned yet, but that’s typical for any TV program. While I won’t say we’re overly confident—tempting fate and all—we’re feeling quite positive and will continue pushing forward.”
Davies also mentioned that lead star Ncuti Gatwa, 31, will be starring in the play “The Importance of Being Earnest” at the National Theatre in November, with plans to resume shooting afterward. The latest series of Doctor Who premiered on May 11, marking Gatwa’s debut in a full series alongside Millie Gibson as his companion Ruby Sunday.
The series made headlines by releasing two episodes, “Space Babies” and “The Devil’s Chord,” on the same day—a first for the show. Fans eagerly welcomed the new series, expressing particular acclaim for the latter episode over the former.
Amidst the overall positive reception, one aspect of the show failed to resonate with viewers: a musical number featured in the Christmas special. Following the defeat of Jinkx Monsoon’s villainous Maestro, the characters found themselves at Abbey Road studios, where a surprising musical montage ensued, including appearances by Strictly Come Dancing’s Shirley Ballas and Johannes Radabe.
Despite the characters’ enthusiasm, viewers took to social media to voice their dissatisfaction. Criticisms ranged from the quality of the song chosen to the appropriateness of its inclusion, with some suggesting that using a Beatles song would have been more fitting.
As Doctor Who navigates its latest series under Davies’ guidance and Gatwa’s lead, the show continues to captivate audiences while grappling with the challenges of evolving storytelling and fan expectations in an ever-changing television landscape.
About the Author
